Performance Evaluation Using Variable Frequency Drive in Pumping Application: A Case Study at Akim Oda Upstream Water Treatment Plant | IJEEE – Volume 9 -Issue 2 | IJEEE-V9I2P11
International Journal of Electrical Engineering and Ethics
ISSN: 2456-9771 | Peer‑Reviewed Open Access Journal
Volume 9, Issue 2
|
Published:
Author
John Kofi Hagan, Solomon Nunoo, David Laud Amenyo Fiase
Abstract
This study is aimed at evaluating the optimal number of pumps required to operate a pumping plant efficiently to obtain a maximum energy savings. One of the evaluative problems being faced currently by the Ghana Water Company Ltd at Akim Oda water treatment plant is the high-energy consumption as a result of the use of single pump in the operations. Since commencing operations in 2018, the system had comprised of five pumps and VFDs integrated with a PLC and SCADA. In motor life cycle, pump cost is 10% and energy consumption 90%, thus considerable improvement in energy savings is possible by increasing the energy efficiency of the pumping system. The main problem with these induction motors is their high-power consumption. In the present study, modelling, simulation and performance evaluation of a variable frequency drive using Matlab/Simulink model was carried out. The experimental results show that the cost of electrical power consumption in kilowatt hour per month for operating the plant with closed-loop and open-loop speed control using VFD are GH¢23,049,289.72 and GH¢33,853,644.28, respectively. Simulations result also show that closed-loop control is advantageous for applications requiring high accuracy, efficiency, and responsiveness as it uses feedback to monitor and correct speed. Hence, per the experimental and simulation results, it is concluded that increasing the number of pumps with closed-loop for their operations will optimise the plant’s performance by enhancing its efficiency and also save energy.
Keywords
Centrifugal pump, variable frequency drive (VFD), Motor speed control, efficiency, parallel pumps, Energy saving, Optimising, Pulse Width Modulation (PWM), Water Treatment Plant (WTP).Conclusion
This study has given the opportunity to assess and evaluate how VFDs can optimise the efficiency, save energy and reduce costs of operation at the Akim Oda water treatment plant. In motor life cycle, pump cost is 10% and energy consumption 90%, also according to green energy savings the amount of work or load on a motor is equal to amount of energy to power the work. VFD is a very cost-effective technology that can lead to better process control, so motor consume less power. The experimental results show that energy consumption per month for operating the plant with closed-loop and open-loop speed control with VFD are 41% and 59%, respectively. To evaluate the plant operation, MATLAB/Simulink was also used to simulate the system to observe the motor speed considering using closed-loop and open-loop speed control. The result shows that for high- precision with significant load variations, closed-loop control offers superior performance. Hence per the experimental and simulation results observation, it can be concluded that increasing the number of pumps for their operations optimise the plants performance by enhancing its efficiency and also save energy.
References
[1]Anibal, T. D. A., Fernando, J. T. E. and Dick, B. (2005), “Technical and Economic Considerations in the Application of Variable-Speed Drives with Electric Motor Systems”, IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications. VOL. 41. NO. 1, January/February.
[2]Ankur, P. D., Rakesh, J. M., Ajitsinh, R. C. (2014), “Energy Conservation Using Variable Frequency Drive in Pumping Application”, ISSN: 2321-9939.
[3]Arun, S. V. K., Umashaankar, S., Paramasivan, S., Norbert, H. (2017), “Real Time Simulation of Variable Speed Parallel Pumping System” Energy Procedia, Volume 142, December 2017, pp:
[4]Blaabjerg, F. (2018), Control of Power Electronic Converters and Systems, Academic Publishers, London, UK.
[5] Cliff, O. M. (2015), Industrial Machine Control, Rift Valley Institute of Science and Technology, Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering.
[6]Ghulam, A., Mahnoor, M., Bukhari, S.S.H. (2019), “Matlab/Simulink Modelings and Experimental Design of Variable Frequency Drive for Speed Control of Three-Phase Induction Motor”, International Journal of Recent Technology and Engineering (IJRTE). ISSN: 2277-3878 (Online), Volume-8Issue-2, July 2019.
[7] Enemuoh, F.O., Okafor, E.E., Onuegbu, J.C., Agu, V.N. (2013), “Modelling, Simulation and Performance Analysis of Induction Motor”, Internation Journal of Engineering Inventions, e-ISSN: 2278-7461. P-ISSN: 2319-6491, Volume 3, Issue 5 (December 2013)
pp: 36-41.
[8]Erickson, R. W. and Makssimovic, D. (2020), Fundamentals of power Electronics, Springer Publication, New York, United States of America, 3rddition, 1741 pp.
[9]Modi, P. N. and Seth, S. M. (2007), Hydraulics and Fluid Mechanics Including Hydraulic Machines, Rajinder Kumar Jain publication, New Delhi, India, Sixteenth Edition, pp: 1059-1084.
[10]Muhammad, H. R. (2018), Power Electronics: Devices, Circuits and Applications, Pearson Publication, London, United Kingdom, 4th Edition, 1024 pp.
[11]Priyanka, P. B., Tushar, M. K., and Rushikesh, S. Z. (2017), “Energy Conservation by Energy Efficient Drive”, International Conference on Innovations in Information, Embedded and Communication Systems (ICIIECS).
[12]Tom, N. and Steven, B. W. (2012), “Variable Frequency Drives: Energy savings for pumping Applications”, Industry Application IA04008002E.
[13]Trzynadlowski, A. M. (2010), Introduction to Modern Power Electronics, John Wiley & Sons, Hoboken 3rd edition, NJ.